New Stitch Fix Review (#42)!


Hip hip hooray, it’s Stitch Fix review day! It’s been a while since I’ve done one of these. I had reset my Fix schedule to “every other month” instead of every month because my SF stylist is getting a little too good at finding pieces I end up buying. I guess that’s the point, but it gets expensive if you end up buying things too often. So, I cut back on my frequency to save a little $.


So when Stitch Fix 42 arrived on my doorstep the other day, I was chomping at the bit to get that box open and try things on. I have to say, this was the most colorful and fun Fix yet! Here’s what I received….




1. Market & Spruce “Desha” Cold Shoulder Knit Top ($44)

Stitch Fix Market & Spruce Cold Shoulder Knit Top

Eeeeek! The pattern of this knit top is so beautiful! It’s kind of a mix of watercolor/painterly flowers and bold navy/black lines: a total work of art if you ask me. It’s a stretchy, but drapey material, so it’s not too big, not too flowy, not too tight, and actually, just right. But the best feature of all is the wide straps at the top! This right here is the closest thing you will ever see me wearing to an “off-the-shoulder” top, folks. I just don’t like the idea of them. My worst-case-scenario oriented mind envisions some mishap where my off-the-shoulder shirt gets tugged on from below (a clingy toddler or hungry goat scenario perhaps?) and ends up around my waist. Unlikely? Yes, but there it is. These two glorious straps are an insurance policy covering my worst fear, so therefore, I had to get this top. (Logical, no?)

Verdict: Kept it


2. Kut From The Kloth “Candace” Split Hem Skinny Jean ($78)

Stitch Fix Kut from the Kloth Candace Split Hem Skinny Jean in Red

Red jeans are all over Instagram this spring, and this is one great pair. The material is lighter weight so they would work for spring or summer, and there is a good deal of stretch to the material. The length was good, although even though they were meant to be ankle length, they were a little longer on me (had to hike them up). And sometimes I think the back pockets of Kut from the Kloth jeans are spaced too widely — at least for my backside — and look a little off. The pockets of these jeans are closer together and so the view is better than usual. I really wanted to keep these jeans. The only reason I didn’t is that I’m trying to not buy as many “trendy” pieces aside from accessories or maybe things that are dirt cheap. I absolutely loved these now, but wasn’t sure they’re something I’d be wearing in the winter — or even next spring. I reluctantly sent them back, but am still having second thoughts.

Verdict: Sent them back

3. Papermoon “Anica” One Pocket Knit Top ($44)

Stitch Fix Papermoon Anica One Pocket Knit Stripe Top

You can check out the front side of this cute knit top in the photo above. I like that it has the one blue stripe on the front pocket. What I like even more about this top is the snap detailing up the back. The snaps don’t actually unsnap (I checked — you know, in case of toddlers or goats tugging on my shirts and unsnapping them when I’m not looking) — they’re just for decoration. The shape and fit of this top are perfect just like the other one: no drooping, nothing too tight, and no awkwardness. This was very cute and comfy, but at the end of the day, I already have probably 5 striped white and black tees and this one wasn’t different enough from the others for me to want to make space in my closet.

Verdict: Sent it back


4. Andrew Marc Performance “Coco” Graphic Knit Top ($34)

Stitch Fix Andrew Marc Performance Coco Graphic Tee Coffee

This was another top that fit me like a glove. It was soft and the lettering is exactly the style I like in my graphic tees. The only downside? I don’t drink coffee. Bummer. But this tee was so cute and soft that I put it in my “keep” pile anyway. Who cares if I’m a die-hard matcha green tea drinker? Who cares if I can’t stand coffee? Well, probably no one else would care, and it was a super-cute tee, but I just can’t get around the fact that I’d be wearing a shirt saying something I don’t agree with. I imagined people commenting on the tee or asking about it and me having to say, “Well, I don’t actually like coffee.” That would be weird and awkward — even more weird and awkward than conversations usually go when I’m involved — so I ended up sending it back.

Verdict: Sent it back


5. Fantasia Accessories “Abigale” Woven Tote ($34)

Stitch Fix Fantasia Abigale Woven Tote Tribal

Isn’t this tote beautiful? I’ve actually been looking for a tote just like this for about a year. I can picture carrying this tote wearing a white tee and some cut-off jean shorts and my beloved Birks. Did you see those pom pom tassels? It’s the perfect summer tote! Except I just bought my perfect summer STRAW tote for my summer vacation capsule wardrobe because I had given up on finding something like this beauty. Alas, I can’t justify buying two new totes for summer, no matter how much I wish I had known this one was coming.

Verdict: Sent it back


See how amazing this fun, cheerful tote looks with the graphic tee and red pants that I also didn’t keep. 🙁

Stitch Fix Review Spring Summer 2018



In all, this 42nd Stitch Fix was one of my most favorite of all time. It was so vibrant, fresh, and fun! This Fix truly represents my “ideal” style, which I would define as casual-comfy-bright-simple-fun. I could wear styles like these every single day.


The Perfect Mother’s Day Gift!

Stitch Fix is so much fun! Take it from me, from that first box to the 42nd one 4 years later, the excitement you feel when you see a Stitch Fix box on your doorstep is real.


Did you know you can give people Stitch Fix Gift Cards in either email or print-at-home format? If you’re like me, sometimes you wait until the last minute and then end up getting a gift card for people because (a) you can’t think of anything else and (b) there’s no time for that anyway. Okay, that’s what I do pretty much all the time. But instead of getting the gold standard Amazon or Target gift card for the moms in your life, try Stitch Fix this year. Trust me, they’ll love it!


Stitch Fix works for anyone: they can do maternity and plus styles, Fixes with premium brands, and they also have men’s Fixes. My husband wears the same 3-4 polo shirts and khaki pants I’m trying to get him to try a men’s Stitch Fix as a gift to ME! Maybe for our anniversary in June….I have a few months to work on it.


everyday teacher style signature

DISCLOSURE: This post contains affiliate links. Clicking on these links may result in my earning a small commission or referral fee. As always, all opinions expressed here are 100% my own. Money earned from using affiliate links helps support this little blog, so I truly appreciate your use of these links.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *